Road Closures Can Be Good

author photo

By Karen Sternheimer

What comes to mind when you hear the phrase “road closed?” Delay? Frustration? Construction?

If so, you are thinking about roads as primarily for cars. But cars aren’t the only use for streets. In car-centric cities, like the one I live in, streets can be conduits for communities as well. Public spaces shape social interactions, and spaces built primarily for cars tend to separate us from one another. Our interactions as drivers are at best limited, and can be uncivil.

Ciclovía—which means “bike path” in Spanish— is a world-wide movement to open streets to pedestrians and cyclists. Temporary road closures enable people to experience cities and their communities differently. These events are meant to help create a greater sense of connection to communities. The little shop or café that you never noticed driving by might be a place to check out and maybe stop for lunch. Being car-free slows things down and encourages us to interact with one another more.

In Los Angeles, a nonprofit organization called CicLAvia has created dozens of events since 2010. Their website describes the purpose of the events:

While each CicLAvia event is a single-day experience, the collective impact of our programming extends beyond any one moment. Ultimately, CicLAvia is more than a day without cars. It is a catalyst for change that reshapes how we move, how we connect, and how we care for one another.

Roads that are typically host to LA’s infamous traffic are transformed for a day into public gathering spaces. I have had the opportunity to experience two CicLAvias in the past year, since temporarily relocating to another part of town. I had never thought about participating in a CicLAvia event in my previous community, mainly because there is limited public transportation there and I would have had to drive and find parking. The whole point of CicLAvia is to get out of your car; events often specifically target the busiest thoroughfares in town.

The LA Metro system has been a regular sponsor of CicLAvia, encouraging people to use public transportation and reduce traffic and the corresponding environmental costs. These events are often strategically located near major transportation hubs to encourage people to try buses or the city’s relatively new rail lines.

A recent event was called “Meet the Hollywoods,” which closed nearly all of Hollywood Boulevard and spanned three communities: East Hollywood, Hollywood, and West Hollywood. Not only is this route home to the historic Hollywood Walk of Fame, but to four Metro rail stops along the way.

Being just a short distance from East Hollywood, I used the opportunity to get in a long training run. I did an out and back, running to the event and the more than 6 miles of closed roads and turned around at the far point. This was nearly 16 miles, with more than 12 miles of the route closed to traffic.

I got started a couple of hours before the event officially began but after the roads were closed—preferring to avoid crowds for much of the time. With portable bathrooms and water stops along the way, as well as volunteers setting up booths and traffic enforcement working major intersections (where traffic could go through when lights changed), there were plenty of people and lots of opportunities for interactions.

Hollywood Boulevard closed to traffic, photo courtesy of the author

Local community groups and businesses had booths along the sidewalk, some offering small freebies or merchandise for sale. At the end of Hollywood Boulevard & Highland Avenue a giant screen broadcast the World Cup Final match between Argentina and Spain.

Restaurants set up extra outdoor seating, and AARP sponsored a board game play zone. Strangers could presumably interact over a game of Candy Land or Connect 4 at the table pictured below. Other vintage board games awaited on tables.

Photo courtesy of the author

The World Economic Forum studied 50 years of Ciclovía worldwide and concluded that these experiences can be transformative, encouraging alternatives to commuting by car, healthier living, and promote a sense of safety for people who might otherwise be afraid to be on public streets.

While CicLAvia events take place only every so often in Los Angeles, a Project for Public Spaces post from 2011 argues:

Ciclovia events can also be powerful transportation planning tools to facilitate discussion around bike-ped issues, catalyze demonstration projects for context sensitive streets, and lay the groundwork for long-term multi-modal investments that can improve mobility and turn streets into quality public spaces.

The experience of these events can push urban planning to set aside car-free spaces to encourage interaction between diverse members of communities who might not otherwise encounter one another.

These events are not cheap for cities, and are subject to complaints that the events benefit some but not all community members. It has cost the city of Los Angeles upwards of $500,000 for each event. Consider the labor involved in creating road closures and traffic control officers to protect public safety. I have seen cars breach the closed zone twice, with traffic enforcement having to stop them before injuring a participant. The cost of portable bathrooms, water, and other expenses add up, although participation is free.

Views of Los Angeles from CicLAvia event The Heart of LA. Photos courtesy of the author.

With the 2028 Olympics approaching, funding was at risk of being cut dramatically. The organizers of CicLAvia reached out to the public, and thousands of public comments supporting open street initiatives flooded social media and political leaders’ email accounts and voicemails.

In 1982, the band Missing Persons had a hit called “Nobody Walks in LA.” A 2016 movie of the same name drew on the transformative power of walking in spaces that are usually driven. CicLAvia, and other similar open street initiatives demonstrate that cities can be transformed—as can their inhabitants—just by being in them together.

Leave a Reply